DOC

MO Japan Affirmative - National Deate Coaches Association

By Debra Jones,2014-01-25 02:07
9 views 0
MO Japan Affirmative - National Deate Coaches AssociationMo,Deate

MO Japan Aff DDI 2010

    1

    PLAN TEXT ..................................................................................................................................................... 4 1AC (1/17) ........................................................................................................................................................ 5 ** Uniqueness ** ............................................................................................................................................ 24 Presence Unpopular ......................................................................................................................................... 25 Presence Unpopular ......................................................................................................................................... 27 AT: Pullout Now ............................................................................................................................................. 28 AT: Pullout Now ............................................................................................................................................. 29 Okinawans Blame Japan .................................................................................................................................. 30 Okinawa kills relations .................................................................................................................................... 31 Relations Strained Now ................................................................................................................................... 32 Japan wants US out.......................................................................................................................................... 33 Relations Brink ................................................................................................................................................ 34 ** Alliance Advantage ** ................................................................................................................................ 35 Japan Wants US out ......................................................................................................................................... 36 Japan Hates bases ............................................................................................................................................ 37 Bases Kill US-Japan treaty .............................................................................................................................. 38 Base Kills Alliance .......................................................................................................................................... 39 Bases Kill Alliance .......................................................................................................................................... 40 Alliance Good Japan Rearm .......................................................................................................................... 41 Removal furthers alliance ................................................................................................................................ 42 Re-Arm Scenario East Asia War ................................................................................................................... 43 Re-Arm Scenario North Korean Prolif .......................................................................................................... 44 Re-Arm Scenario North Korean Prolif .......................................................................................................... 45 Ext. Japan Can Arm Now ............................................................................................................................. 46 Alliance Good - Heg (Troops) ......................................................................................................................... 47 Alliance Good - Heg (Relations) ..................................................................................................................... 48 Alliance Good Asian War ............................................................................................................................. 49 Alliance Good Asian War ............................................................................................................................. 50 Alliance Good Asian War ............................................................................................................................. 51 Alliance Good Middle East ........................................................................................................................... 52 Alliance Good Prolif ..................................................................................................................................... 53 Alliance Good Prolif ..................................................................................................................................... 54 Alliance Good Spartlys ................................................................................................................................. 55 Alliance Good Arabs .................................................................................................................................... 56 Alliance Good Taiwan .................................................................................................................................. 57 Alliance Good Taiwan .................................................................................................................................. 58 Alliance Good North Korea .......................................................................................................................... 59 Alliance Good Sino-Russia ........................................................................................................................... 60 Alliance Good Sino-Russia ........................................................................................................................... 61 Alliance Good China .................................................................................................................................... 63 Relations on the Brink Now ............................................................................................................................. 64 Relations on the Brink Now ............................................................................................................................. 65 Relations on the Brink Now ............................................................................................................................. 66 Alliance Brinks ................................................................................................................................................ 67 Alliance Brink ................................................................................................................................................. 69 Last printed 2/25/2014 11:47:00 PM 1

MO Japan Aff DDI 2010

    1 Japan Alliance Pwns ........................................................................................................................................ 73 Asia Loves the Alliance ................................................................................................................................... 74 Japan loves Alliance ........................................................................................................................................ 75 AT: China Threat key to Alliance .................................................................................................................... 76 ** Environmental Advantage ** ...................................................................................................................... 77 Greatest Stuff Ever - DUGONG ADVANTAGE!!!.......................................................................................... 78 Greatest Stuff Ever - DUGONG ADVANTAGE!!!.......................................................................................... 79 Greatest Stuff Ever - DUGONG ADVANTAGE!!!.......................................................................................... 80 Bases Bad Environment ................................................................................................................................ 81 Bases Bad - Coral Reef .................................................................................................................................... 82 Coral Reefs Good- Biodiversity ....................................................................................................................... 83 Coral Reef Extinction = Disease ...................................................................................................................... 84 2AC Add-on Environment (1/2)....................................................................................................................... 85 ** Marines Advantage ** ................................................................................................................................ 87 Marines Uniqueness ........................................................................................................................................ 88 Marines on Okinawa ........................................................................................................................................ 89 Marines Are Awesomesauce ............................................................................................................................ 90 Marines beatdown Terrorists............................................................................................................................ 91 Marines Kill Terrorists..................................................................................................................................... 92 AT: Marines bad .............................................................................................................................................. 93 AT: Army Solves ............................................................................................................................................. 94 ** Politics Advantage ** ................................................................................................................................. 95 Okinawa Link .................................................................................................................................................. 96 Politics Scenario Econ 1/2 ............................................................................................................................ 97 Politics Scenario Econ 2/2 ............................................................................................................................ 99 2AC Warming Add-on................................................................................................................................... 100 1AR Climate Change Japan can lead ........................................................................................................... 101 1AR Climate Change Helps Econ ............................................................................................................... 102 Uniqueness - Kan Pushing Reform ................................................................................................................ 103 Impact Timeframe 3 Years/Japan on the Brink............................................................................................ 104 ** Solvency ** .............................................................................................................................................. 105 Withdrawal Solves 1/3 ................................................................................................................................... 106 Withdrawal Solves 2/3 ................................................................................................................................... 107 Withdrawal Solves 3/3 ................................................................................................................................... 108 Removal Key- Alliance ................................................................................................................................. 110 Removal Key- Stops Backlash ....................................................................................................................... 111 Relations Solvency ........................................................................................................................................ 112 Relations Solvency ........................................................................................................................................ 113 Relations Solvency ........................................................................................................................................ 115 Random East Asian Stability Card ................................................................................................................. 116 Presence Bad ................................................................................................................................................. 117 Troop presence bad ........................................................................................................................................ 118 AT: Rearm DA .............................................................................................................................................. 119 AT: Rearm DA .............................................................................................................................................. 120 Withdrawal Popular ....................................................................................................................................... 121 ** Varun Cuts lots of Random Cards ** ........................................................................................................ 122 Last printed 2/25/2014 11:47:00 PM 2

MO Japan Aff DDI 2010

    1 Presence key to Japanese Economy................................................................................................................ 123 Okinawa = Military Presence ......................................................................................................................... 124 T Link In = Throughout .............................................................................................................................. 125 American Action Key .................................................................................................................................... 126 Women = Raped/SOFAs Bad ........................................................................................................................ 127 AT: T Substantial........................................................................................................................................ 128 American Influence in Japanese = Real World ............................................................................................... 129 Consultation Now/Key to Solve the Aff/SoKo Prolif Good (Check China) .................................................... 130 Japan key to East Asian Security ................................................................................................................... 131 Solvency Checks China & East Asia Stuff .................................................................................................. 132 Taiwan, China, NoKo Stability ...................................................................................................................... 133 AT: Consult Japan CP ................................................................................................................................... 134

    Last printed 2/25/2014 11:47:00 PM 3

MO Japan Aff DDI 2010

    1

    PLAN TEXT

     The United States Federal Government should remove all military presence from Okinawa, Japan.

    Last printed 2/25/2014 11:47:00 PM 4

    MO Japan Aff DDI 2010

    1

    1AC (1/17)

    Contention 1 is the Japanese Alliance

    Okinawa has pushed the US-Japan alliance to the brink

    Eric Talmadge - The Associated Press, 7/22/2010, ―Okinawa basing stresses U.S.-