Government of Jammu & Kashmir
Office of the Development Commissioner (Power)
Janipur, Jammu, J&K
E-mail : email@example.com, firstname.lastname@example.org, email@example.com,
Telephone No’s: 0191 – 2532809, 2534284, Fax: 0191 – 2530265
Engagement of a consultant to assist J&K Power Development Department
Conducting Transmission and Distribution Loss Study
Terms Of Reference
1. Objective of the Engagement
1.1. The power sector in the State of Jammu and Kashmir is governed by two
different legislations, namely, the J&K Electricity Act 2010 and the J&K
Electricity Duty Act 1963
1.2. Generation of power is entrusted with the state owned J & K State Power
Development Corporation (JKSPDC).
1.3. Transmission and distribution of electricity are entrusted with the Government
department, namely the Power Development Department (PDD), hereinafter
referred to as the Department or PDD.
1.4. The J&K State Electricity Regulatory Commission, hereinafter referred to as
JKSERC, was established under the repealed J&K State Electricity Regulatory
Commission Act, 2000. The JKSERC issued first Tariff Order for 2007-08 on
thndMarch 28, 2007, 2 Tariff Order for 2008-09 on 12-09-2008 and third tariff
order for 2010-11 on 29-04-2010.
1.4.1. As provided under Clauses 4.27 of the Tariff Order for 2007-08 and clause
11.2& Clause 11.3 of the Tariff Order 2008-09, the Commission has issued
following directive to PDD, regarding T&D losses:
1.4.2. Clause 4.27 of Tariff Order for 2007-08: The Commission directs the
utility to segregate losses into technical loss and commercial loss; specify a
trajectory for reduction of losses, both technical and commercial, and
develop action plan for achieving loss reduction.
1.4.3. Clause 11.2 of Tariff Order for 2008-09: …….The commission directs the
utility to conduct a detailed loss study on an urgent basis and submit the
Page 1 of 10
findings to the Commission by March 31, 2009. Such loss study should be
realistically able to ascertain/ estimate the following:
(a) Sales in MUs to various consumer categories.
(b) T&D Losses
1.4.4. Clause 11.3 of Tariff Order for 2008-09 The Petitioner shall develop a
detailed plan for conducting the loss study for approval………..
1.5. As can be inferred from the above, the JKSERC wishes PDD to conduct a
detailed study for following:
(a) Estimation of realistic T&D Losses
(b) Segregation of T&D Losses into Transmission and Distribution Losses
(c) Segregation of T&D losses into Technical and Commercial Losses
(d) Sales in MUs to various consumer categories
(e) Specify Loss reduction trajectory
(f) Develop action plan for loss reduction
Consumer categories are as under;
3. Power Intensive
d) State Govt.
e) Central Govt.
g) Irrigation / Tube well
1.6. Accordingly PDD intends to engage a consultant to assist it in conducting of
detailed loss study and realistically ascertain/estimate the Transmission Losses,
Distribution Losses and segregate the T&D losses into technical and commercial
losses besides ascertaining the sales in MUs to various categories of consumers
and specifying loss reduction trajectory and developing of action plan for
2. Brief Description of the Power Development Department (PDD)
Page 2 of 10
2.1. The Power Development Department (PDD) manages operations related to transmission and distribution of electricity within the State of Jammu & Kashmir, involving –
2.1.1. Design, erection, commissioning,, operation and maintenance of the
transmission and distribution networks,
2.1.2. Supplying power to consumers, and
2.1.3. Realization of revenue from consumers.
2.2. To undertake these works, various activities have been entrusted to different wings of the Department as under:
2.2.1. Maintenance and RE (M&RE) Wing: In charge of the sub-transmission and
distribution network (i.e. up to 66 KV level) of the two regions,, and
associated activities related to infrastructure development, operation &
maintenance, and recovery of tariff from the consumers.
2.2.2. System and Operation (S&O) Wing: In charge of the transmission
networks i.e. from 132 KV to 220 KV level, and associated activities related
to infrastructure development, operation and maintenance. 2.2.3. P&MM Wing: In charge of procurement of material use in the sub-
transmission and distribution network (up to 66 KV level). 2.2.4. P&D Wing: In charge of the planning of network system and procurement
of material for use in transmission network (above 66 KV level). 2.2.5. Commercial & Survey (C&S) Wing: In charge of the procurement of
power, coordination with SLDC, and operation of PLCC network. 2.3. PDD purchases power from the CPSUs like NHPC, NTPC, THDC, SJVNL and NPCIL besides the PDC, and trading companies like NVVN and PTC. 2.4. Power is supplied to the consumers over the transmission and distribution networks comprising of 220 KV, 132 KV, 66 KV, 33 KV, 11 KV lines. 2.5. The sub-stations where the voltage transformation takes place are managed by the S&O Wings & M&RE Wings depending upon the voltage level. 2.6. The number of sub-stations at various voltage levels is as follows:
Jammu Kashmir Total
220/132 KV 4 2 6
132/66-33 KV 19 18 37
66-33/11-6.6 KV 218 199 417
11/0.43kV 15652 15390 31042
Page 3 of 10
2.7. The lengths of the transmission and distribution lines at different voltage levels are as follows:
(figures in Km.) Jammu Kashmir Total
220 KV 402.80 200.00 602.80
132 KV 858.06 725 1583.06
66 KV 214.30 - 214.30
33 KV 1965.13 1472.90 3438.03
11-6.6 KV 15103.15 10738.65 25841.80
LT lines 35061.68 32313.57 67375.25
2.8. PDD achieved 100% feeder metering in March, 2007. The current level of consumer metering is around 50% and DTR metering is yet to be taken up.
3. Scope of Work
3.1. In order to enable PDD to comply to the directives of JKSERC under the Tariff Order 2007-08 and Tariff Order 2008-09 and to enable it to know realistic technical and commercial losses at various voltage levels and to chalk out a comprehensive strategy for reduction of these losses to acceptable at primary & secondary distribution levels , PDD has decided to engage a consultant to assist it in conducting detailed loss study which shall include following: (a) Estimation of realistic T&D Losses
(b) Segregation of T&D Losses into Transmission and Distribution Losses (c) Segregation of T&D losses into Technical and Commercial Losses (d) Sales in MUs to various consumer categories
(e) Specify Loss reduction trajectory
(f) Develop action plan for loss reduction
(g) Any other activity/ies not covered above but considered necessary for
conducting loss study of a Transmission and Distribution Utility
(h) From the measured data, reliability indices like SAFI and SAIDI for
the stations of PDD should be calculated.
(i) Forecast load M&RE circle wise and from there for entire PDD and
calculate correlation factor between load growth and losses.
3.2. The consultant would be expected to act as a T&D loss study expert with in-depth knowledge of Transmission and Distribution Sector.
Page 4 of 10
3.3. PDD expects the consultant to execute the entire assignment as per the guidelines
outlined below; however, PDD is open to alternate plans / guidelines if such
plans were found to be more efficient. The consultant is supposed to address the
specified guidelines while submitting the proposal to PDD. Some of the
guidelines also indicate the specific tasks expected to be undertaken, during the
engagement, for the benefit of the consultant and the consultant is supposed to
submit a work plan on the basis of such tasks. However, it should be noted that
the Consultant is expected to perform all such tasks required for the successful
implementation of the proposed system and not restrict the scope to those
3.4. The consultant shall also be responsible for training to be provided to the relevant
staff of PDD. The various phases along with the specific sub-tasks the consultant
is expected to perform are outlined below.
3.5. Brief Methodology
Step 1: Selection of sample size
The transmission system at 66kV and above would be fully represented for estimating the Transmission losses. However the sample size for the distribution loss study should be atleast four feeders per M&RE circle in the 66 KV-33KV level, eight feeders per M&RE circle in the 11 KV-6.6.KV level and 50% DTRs on the sampled 11 KV -6.6 KV feeders. Feeders should be selected such that minimum 2% consumers in the respective M&RE circle are covered. Similarly, 50% DTRs should be selected such that all types of DTRs are covered.
Step 2: Total energy loss estimation
All the energy input/output at each voltage level shall be measured during a specified period. Similarly the aggregate of all the direct consumption at that voltage level shall also be taken into account corresponding to the specified period. The difference between the input and output readings/aggregated sales at each voltage level gives the net energy lost at that voltage level during the period of study. These percentage energy losses for each voltage level and for the specified period shall be extrapolated to compute the annual energy loss at that voltage level for the system. In J&K there is lot of seasonal variation in energy consumption and as such the measurement of input/output shall have to be carried out over a period of 12 months in order to cover all the seasons of the year and to have fairly correct and acceptable data.
Step 3: Technical loss estimation
The technical energy losses of the sample network shall be estimated by simulating the system on the computer corresponding to average peak load condition. The peak power losses for each identified sample network shall be assessed on the basis of computer load flow studies. The load factor & loss load factor (LLF) will be worked out from daily load curves. The peak power loss will be then, converted in to energy loss by applying the loss load factor & the time period of study.
Page 5 of 10
Step4: Commercial loss computation
The difference of the total energy loss as obtained from energy audit and the technical energy loss computed from load flow study gives the commercial energy loss.
3.6 Experience sharing
PDD understands that similar studies have been conducted in various other
states of India, for a similar purpose. To the extent possible, the consultant
would conduct the study considering the same practices so as to ensure
precision in estimation and planning.
3.7 Training Needs Analysis (TNA)
The consultant will keep PDD informed about the activities of studies and
their progress. Consultant PDD & representative of commission will be
monitoring progress quarter wise. A third party examiner / monitor from
CEA, New Delhi will associate the studies. The consultant will outline the
training requirements to ensure successful implementation and will, at an
early stage of the engagement, assist PDD in the identification of the
necessary personnel, and ensure their involvement throughout the process
of conducting the study. The consultant will ensure to impart adequate
training to the staff of PDD, especially those who will be directly involved
during the implementation phase, so as to ensure their common
understanding of the T&D loss study and loss reduction techniques. 3.8 Documentation
At least 10 copies of each report shall be provided by the consultant for
review and approval of PDD. The consultant shall be responsible to
incorporate comments of PDD and furnish at least 10 copies of revised
report, within the time frame agreed upon. The consultant may have to
issue more than one revision of the report so as to prepare it fully up to the
satisfaction of the PDD/JKSERC.
4. Bid Qualification Requirements:
The Bidder shall become eligible to bid on satisfying the following “Bid Qualification requirements” and on production of the required documentary evidences
along with the Tender:
a) The bidder company should be a company registered in India under the
Companies Act, 1956.
b) The bidder must have executed energy audit/accounting project for at least
one power utility in India in the last five years.
Page 6 of 10
c) The bidder must have conducted technical loss study in the
transmission/distribution network of a transmission/distribution licensee in
India using load flow software tools in the last five years.
d) Bidder should have cumulative turnover of Rs.100.00 cores over a period of
five years. Certified balance sheets for the same have to be attached in support
of the above.
e) Bidder shall submit documentary evidences in support of the above. The
bidder shall have the required hardware/software tools for carrying out the
service. Bidder shall give a brief write-up on the facility i.e. hardware
software tools, available with them.
f) The offers of bidders not satisfying any of the above” Bid qualification
Requirements” shall be rejected.
g) The bidder shall ensure that deputed personnel are trained and experienced for
such jobs for ensuring the high quality and correctness of job so that job is
carried out in a highly professional and sound managerial manner. The bidder
shall furnish documents regarding the experience of the key personnel
proposed to be employed by him.
h) Mere submission of the proposal will not confer any right for allotment of
contract, J&K PDD reserves the right to reject any or all the applications or
stop the process of this proposal at any stage, at its sole discretion.
4.1 The bidder must have a sound understanding of:
; The legal and regulatory framework governing the power sector, in
general, and the State of Jammu & Kashmir, in specific.
; Energy auditing and loss study of utilities engaged in Transmission and
Distribution of Electricity,
; Experience of tariff principles applicable to Indian power sector sound
technical knowledge base of electrical networks and metering at LT, HV
and EHV levels
4.2 The term „bidder‟ and „consultant‟ are used interchangeably and refer either to a
consultant or a consortium, which the consultant may constitute with other agencies, as it deems fit for being associated with, for the purpose of bidding for this engagement. Where a consortium bids for the engagement, written consent from each member of the consortium has to be included in the proposal.
4.3 The Power Development Department may refer the deliverables of the engagement to JKSERC for their comments, if required. It shall be obligatory for the consultant to incorporate their comments also in all such deliverables / to extent feasible.
4.4 The bidder shall also provide training to the departmental staff in conducting the loss study. The training shall be given to at least two batches of 40 employees from Jammu Province and 40 employees from Kashmir Province.
Page 7 of 10
Sl. Criteria Sub Points Points
1 General Qualifications 20
a) Professional Education and Relevant Training 5
b) Position held, experience and time with the consulting firm 5
c) Position held, experience and time other than consulting firm 5
d) Position held in MIS, Technical, and Operational issues 5
2 Adequacy for the project 70
a) Involvement in number of projects having more than 30 man- 15
month of effort completed
b) Number of years of relevant consulting experience in the power 20
c) Exposure to proposed task assigned in number of states and 35
3 Experience in State and language Proficiency and good command 10 10
over English and Hindi/Urdu languages
Total Points 100
The minimum technical score required to pass is: 75 points.
Evaluation for Financial Proposals; Ranking
i) A two-stage procedure will be adopted in evaluating the proposals with the
technical evaluation being completed prior to any financial proposals being
opened. The decision of the award of the contract would be as under:
Technical proposals scoring not less than 75% of the technical score will only
be considered for financial evaluation.
The highest technically ranked firm will be allotted a Technical Score(T) of
100, and all other firms would be scored pro-rata. The lowest financial
proposal will be allotted a Financial Score of 100, and all other firms would
be scored pro-rata.
The total score for each firm would be calculated as 0.65* Technical
Score+0.35* Financial Score.
The formula for determining the financial scores is as following
(Sf=100xFm/F, in which Sf is the financial score, Fm is the lowest price and F
the price of the proposal under consideration).
ii) The evaluation shall exclude the taxes, duties fees, levies, and other charges
imposed under the applicable law.
Page 9 of 10
5.0 Period of Completion:-
(i) Measuring of Input / output: 12 months
(ii) Finalization and submission of report: 3 months
(iii) Total Completion period: 15 months
6.0 TERMS OF PAYMENT: -
a) Ten percent (10%) of the contract price after carrying out input / output
measurements for three months.
b) Ten percent (10%) of the contract price after carrying out input / output
measurements for next four months.
c) Twenty percent (20%) of the total contract price after submission of the draft
d) Fifty percent (50%) of the total contract price after submission of the final study
e) Balance ten percent (10%) of the total contract price after completion of work,
and training of staff.
7.0. SECURITY: -
At the time of signing of the Contract Agreement, the consultant shall submit irrevocable bank guarantee towards contract performance security for five percent (5%) of the contract price valid for the term of the contract.
Page 10 of 10