Name class ID phone Email
Tanya 09BA 20093111337 15003663044 09batanya@g
I wouldn’t kill the fat man because of a man can not stop a train even if he is really fat. Furthermore I’m not sure whether this fat man can stop the train but the driver was already dead and still nobody could control the train. For this reason, if I pushed him then there would be a bigger loss. Thirdly, I didn’t the born him and also I am not his
relative, so I don’t have the right to kill him. Finally, if the one hundred passengers are terrorists, then it is not better to save them from the tragedy.
As we know one’s body is smaller than a train one thousand times more, it is very difficult for a man to stop a high speed train even if he is really fat. Because the train is made of the iron and human’s body is made of bone, it is certainly that the iron
breakdown the bone but not the bone break down the iron. Furthermore the fat man may not fall on the train track, but it could be fall on the back of train. And it is certainly that the fat man’s body will become meat juice but not the train becomes the iron juice.
The information gave us that the driver was already dead and it impossible that nobody cam control the loss train. Because if there was someone can control the train, then could have been stop immediately, but not still in a danger. So even if the fat man stop the train, but it is possible that the train loss again. I think there is no necessary to west an additional life.
Killing the fat man is wrong solution to save that problem, because according to the law of our nation, that it’s illegal to take of one’s life and we have gone the prison. I
think this is a stupid behavior to hurt you for save others. I am a Buddhist I know some values of one’s life. The fat man has right to live and I didn’t give him the
birth .I don’t have the right to take away his precious life. Hence, all in all, killing the fat man is the wrong thing to do. The fat man is also a witness for the tragedy and I thin if he really great and know he could stop the train. Then he might be done this help by himself but me to help him. I believe he might take some measures, I may find a better solution by talking to him, it’s better to talk to him rather than push him;
we may had a good decision with an excellent solution to recue those people’s life.
If those hundred passengers are terrorists, then I think there was no reason to save them. Because everyone in this world looking for the peace and development. Those people are a very doggerel to destroy human’s achievement. How can we change one
hundred families sadness to all worlds’ sadness? But the fat man can contribute the
society, and I strongly believe kill the fat man is a wrong thing, I would regret. I wouldn’t kill the fat man because of those above strong reasons. However there is no one’s body can stop the train, also this driver was already dead and nobody can control the train. Furthermore I don’t have the right to kill him because of I didn’t
right to kill him. It is worthless to save one hundred terrorists by killing a great man who were good for contribute the society.