[Draft text for the brochure for INCOSAI]

By Henry Lopez,2014-05-19 04:30
14 views 0
[Draft text for the brochure for INCOSAI]

    INTOSAI Professional Standards Committee

    International Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions

     INTOSAI’s framework of Professional Standards


    The INTOSAI framework of Professional Standards and Guidelines.

The framework is to provide a clear overview and easy access to INTOSAI’s standards and guide-

    lines to the benefit of INTOSAI’s members. In line with INTOSAI’s Strategic Plan, the framework

    should provide greater focus and attention on professional standards and raise the profile and

    status of INTOSAI’s standard-setting process also within the broader accountability commu-nity.

The proposed framework was developed by the PSC Steering Committee during its meetings in

    Oslo, Norway, in October 2005, in Washington, USA, in May 2006 and in Yaoundé, Cameroun, in

    September 2006. The proposal was decided on by INTOSAI’s Governing Board in November

    2006 and an exposure draft was sent to all members of INTOSAI. In the light of the many sup-

    portive comments received, the PSC Steering Committee has decided at its meeting in

    Manama, Bahrain, in April 2007 to forward its proposal for endorsement at the XIX INCOSAI

    in Mexico in November 2007.

The framework presented in this paper is thus the result of the joint efforts of the members of

    the PSC Steering Committee, which includes the SAIs of: Bahrain, Belgium, Brazil, Cameroon,

    Canada, China, Denmark, France, Italy, Morocco, New Zealand, Norway, Portugal, Sweden and


I would like to thank all the member SAIs of the PSC Steering Committee and all other SAIs

    that have contributed to our work for their dedication and cooperation. I would like to direct a

    special thank to the PSC Goal Liaison the SAI of Portugal for the continuous support and

    cooperativeness. A special recognition to the SAIs of Austria, Belgium, Brazil and Bahrain,

    who took on the responsibility of performing translation tasks.

Copenhagen, November 2007

Henrik Otbo

    Auditor General of Denmark,

    Chair of the INTOSAI Professional Standards Committee

    The National Audit Office of Denmark • Landgreven 4 • P.O. Box 9009 • 1022 Copenhagen • Denmark Tel.:+45 3392 8400 • Fax:+45 3311 0415 •E-mail:

    - 2 -


    With the Strategic Plan 2005-2010 INTOSAI made it an ambition under Goal 1 to provide an

    up-to-date framework of professional standards that are relevant for its members. The

    Professional Standards Committee (PSC) therefore decided to merge all existing and new

    INTOSAI standards and guidelines into one common framework under the name Interna-tional Standards of Supreme Auditing Institutions (ISSAI). All standards and guidelines will be available on and will be numbered in accordance with a set of classifi-

    cation principles.

The systematic classification of the document and the new name will help improve the general

    knowledge of standards and guidelines and facilitate their practical use in the INTOSAI com-

    munity and in the public administration in general. The decision by INCOSAI to introduce the

    framework does not affect the content of the already existing documents. As SAIs are national

    authorities it is the responsibility of each SAI to decide on the implementation of the ISSAIs

    on basis of the SAI’s legal mandate.

    The common framework of INTOSAI’s standards and guidelines The framework with all documents contained is available at www. The framework

    follows these principles:

? The framework comprises all documents endorsed by INCOSAI with the purpose of guiding

    the professional standards used by SAIs. The documents are listed in a systematic num-ber system.

    ? The name International Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions (ISSAI) is used as the common name to the body of documents concerning the responsibilities of SAIs. Each

    document will thus get an ISSAI-number.

    ? The name INTOSAI Guidance on Good Governance (INTOSAI GOV) is used for docu-ments issued by INTOSAI concerning guidance to the administrative authorities, e.g. on in-

    ternal controls and accounting. Such documents get a 4-digit INTOSAI GOV-number.

? The framework emphasizes the hierarchical relationship between the documents.

    The number of digits in the ISSAI-number indicates the document’s level in the hierarchy.

The hierarchy of INTOSAI documents

    As emphasized in the preamble to the INTOSAI Code of Ethics and Auditing Standards en-

    dorsed by INCOSAI in 2004, the INTOSAI documents form a four-tier hierarchy:

? Level 1: The Lima Declaration

    ? Level 2: The INTOSAI Code of Ethics.

    ? Level 3: The INTOSAI Auditing Standards which contain the basic assumptions and

    principles for carrying out the audit work.

    ? Level 4: INTOSAI Implementation Guidelines which contain more specific guidance

    material on different subjects.

In the new ISSAI framework the four levels will be developed along the following lines:

Level 1: Founding Principles. This level contains the founding principles of INTOSAI. These

    are found in the Lima Declaration.

    - 3 - Level 2: Prerequisites for the Functioning of Supreme Audit Institutions. Based on the

    founding principles, the documents on this level develop further on the basic prerequisites of

    the proper functioning and professional conduct of SAIs. These documents contain general

    statements and principles on a high level and should not be changed very often. PSC will pro-

    pose a new Mexico Declaration on Independence at the XIX INCOSAI and is planning to devel-

    op principles on transparency and accountability to be endorsed by the XX INCOSAI in 2010.

    The existing Code of Ethics and a future document on audit quality are also referred to this


    Level 3: Fundamental Auditing Principles. Documents on this level are based on level 1 and 2 and contain the fundamental principles for carrying out audits of public entities. Where-

    as institutional issues will be regulated by the documents on level 2, the documents on level 3

    concern issues related to the process of carrying through an audit. The Fundamental Auditing

    Principles presently consist of the INTOSAI Auditing Standards, which contain the following


    1. Basic principles in government auditing contain the audit assumptions/general principles. 2. General Standards in government auditing contain qualification requirements, independence, conflicts of interest, competence and due care etc.

    3. Field Standards in government auditing contain more detailed guidance on for instance planning, evidence, analysis of financial statements, internal control.

    4. Reporting Standards in government auditing contain financial audit reporting (the audit opinion), regularity and performance audit remarks and reporting.

To underline the importance of these standards and allow for flexibility in the future develop-

    ment, each of the 4 chapters is given its own ISSAI-number, and the items within the chap-

    ters are being renumbered accordingly.

    Level 4: Auditing Guidelines: Documents on this level translate the fundamental auditing principles into more specific, detailed and operational guidelines that can be used on a daily

    basis for auditing tasks.

Level 4 will include implementation guidelines for financial audit, performance audit and com-

    pliance audit.

Implementation guidelines for financial audit are being developed by PSC’s Subcommittee on

    Financial Audit Guidelines (FAS). These guidelines concern audit of financial statements and

    are based on the International Standards of Auditing (ISA’s) issued by the International

    Auditing and Assurance Standards Board (IAASB) of the International Federation of Accoun-

    tants (IFAC). An INTOSAI guideline on financial auditing will consist of an ISA issued by

    IAASB together with an INTOSAI Practice Note outlining the modifications and further elabo-

    rations that need to be considered in public auditing. The ISSAI-number contains a reference

    to the ISA-number. The document ISSAI 1240 will for example designate the combined

    document consisting of ISA 240 together with the INTOSAI Practice Note.

Implementation guidelines for performance audit have been endorsed by the INTOSAI Con-

    gress 2004 in Hungary. PSC Subcommittee on Performance Audit, chaired by Brazil, will con-

    sider if supplementary guidance on performance audit is to be developed.

At the XIX INCOSAI in 2007 PSC is also proposing a set of implementation guidelines on

    Compliance Audit. These have been developed by the PSC Compliance Audit Subcommittee

    and will be supplemented with further guidelines in the years to come.

    - 4 -

    Level 4 also contains guidelines and supplementary material on specific subjects, e.g. audit of

    privatisation, public debt, environmental matters and international institutions. Many such

    guidelines have already been developed and endorsed by the INCOSAI. Future documents

    produced under Goal 3 of the Strategic Plan and falling within the scope of the framework will

    also be included under level 4.

INTOSAI Guidance for Good Governance (INTOSAI GOV)

    The scope of INTOSAI’s professional standards is not limited to standards and guidance on

    audit. INTOSAI is also a valuable source of guidance to the benefit of government manage-

    ment on internal control and accounting. These documents do not originate from the INTOSAI

    Auditing Standards but belong to the collection of INTOSAI guidance material and are as such

    included in the framework. To emphasise the importance and distinctive nature of this catego-

    ry of documents, they are named INTOSAI Guidance for Good Governance and the acronym

    INTOSAI GOV is used. The numbers 9000-9999 are reserved for these documents.


    Classification principles for International Standards of Supreme Audit

    Institutions (ISSAI)

    INTOSAI’s Professional Standards Committee will decide on the appropriate classification of

    documents in accordance with the following principles:

    1. The International Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions (ISSAI) consist of all docu-

    ments endorsed by INCOSAI with the purpose of guiding the professional standards of

    SAIs. This includes recommendations on the legal, organisational and professional

    prerequisites as well as on the conduct of the auditing and any other tasks with which

    SAIs may be entrusted. Where appropriate ISSAI-documents may include examples or

    descriptions of good practices.

    2. Each document is given a 1-4 digit ISSAI-number. The number of digits indicates the

    hierarchical level of the document, i.e.:

    Level 1: Founding Principles contains the founding principles of INTOSAI. The Lima


    Level 2: Prerequisites for the Functioning of Supreme Audit Institutions state

    and explain the basic prerequisites for the proper functioning and professional conduct of


    Level 3: Fundamental Auditing Principles contain the fundamental principles in carry-

    ing out auditing of public entities.

    Level 4: Auditing Guidelines translate the fundamental auditing principles into more

    specific, detailed and operational guidelines that can be used on a daily basis for auditing


    3. Preambles or introductory remarks to the original proposals to INTOSAI are not consid-

    ered part of the ISSAIs at level 2, 3 and 4, unless the text contained serves a purpose in

    guiding the professional standards of SAIs. The information contained in such preambles

    and introductory remarks will be published at as additional information in

    connection with the ISSAI-document.

    - 5 -

    4. Document numbers dividable by 1000 (or 100 or 10) are preferably given to documents

    of a general scope while the subsequent numbers x001-x999 (or xx01-xx99 or xxx1-xxx9)

    are used for documents on more specific subjects within the same general theme.

    5. The numbers from 1000-9999 are reserved for level 4 (implementation guidelines) and

    segmented into clusters reserved for different subject areas. The subcommittees of PSC

    and working groups of Goal 3 are responsible for maintaining the classification within their

    subject area.

    6. When convenient, a reference to specific items (or sections and subsections) within an

    ISSAI-document can be made by adding the number of the item to the ISSAI-number

    with a slash ‘/‘. (E.g. ISSAI 3000/5.4 refers to item 5.4 in ISSAI 3000). 7. For documents that have their origin in an ISA (or ISQC) from IFAC/IAASB the last 3 di-

    gits of the ISSAI-number are identical with the ISA-number (or ISQC-number). The

    ISSAI-number designates the ISA with the modifications and supplementary guidance

    contained in the Practice Note. The items in the Practice Notes are numbered P1, P2,

    P3…etc. to avoid confusion with item numbers in the ISA.

    8. When convenient, an ISSAI document may contain an annex containing further elabora-

    tions related to the statements of the main document. Items in the annex should be num-

    bered A1, A2, A3... etc. to avoid confusion with item numbers in the main document.

    It should be emphasized that all existing INTOSAI documents will be included in the


    INTOSAI Guidance for Good Governance (INTOSAI GOV):

    9. INTOSAI Guidance for Good Governance comprises documents endorsed by INCOSAI and

    contains guidance on internal control, accounting standards and other matters within the

    administrative sphere of responsibility. This includes documents, guiding the SAIs in their

    professional assessment of measures taken by administrative authorities or guiding ad-

    ministrative authorities and encouraging good governance.

    10. The numbers 9000-9999 are reserved for this category of documents, and the acronym

    INTOSAI GOV is used instead of ISSAI. With this amendment, the classification principles

    apply also to these documents.

    Other documents:

    11. Other documents such as reports, glossaries, lists of organisations or collections of ex-

    amples for purely inspirational purposes are not numbered. They can be included in the

    framework only as an annex to the relevant ISSAI- or INTOSAI GOV-document.

    The existing document ‘INTOSAI Code of Ethics and Auditing Standards’:

    12. The existing document ‘INTOSAI Code of Ethics and Auditing Standards’ endorsed by

    INCOSAI in 2001 is divided into 5 documents and each is given an ISSAI-number. The

    Code of Ethics belongs to level 2, while each of the 4 chapters of the Auditing Standards

    becomes a document on level 3. The item numbers are changed to the effect that the

    digit indicating the number of the chapter is left out.

    - 6 - Framework of INTOSAI’s standards and guidelines

     Level 3 Fundamental Auditing Principles ISSAI 100 Basic Principles [existing Auditing Standards] ISSAI 200 General Standards [existing Auditing Standards] ISSAI 300 Field Standards [existing Auditing Standards] ISSAI 400 Reporting Standards [existing Auditing Standards] ISSAI 500 [reserved for future principles] ISSAI 600 [reserved for future principles] ISSAI 700 [reserved for future principles] ISSAI 800 [reserved for future principles] ISSAI 900 [reserved for future principles]

    Guidance on Level 4 Auditing Guidelines Accounting Standards ISSAI 1000 2999 Financial Audit Guidelines [planned] Guidance on ? Accounting ISSAI 3000 3999 Performance Audit Guidelines Internal Standards [existing and future] Control Standards Framework ISSAI 4000 4999 Compliance Audit Guidelines [planned] (INTOSAI GOV (INTOSAI GOV ISSAI 5000 5999 Guidelines on Specific Subjects 9100 9199) 9200) [existing and planned] ? ImplementationISSAI 6000 6999 [reserved for future guidelines] ISSAI 7000 7999 [reserved for future

     guidelines] Guidelines ISSAI 8000 8999 [reserved for future guidelines] (INTOSAI GOV 9201 9299)

    Maintaining the framework on

    The framework on will be the primary vehicle for distribution of the Interna-

    tional Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions. PSC will continuously maintain and develop

    the website in accordance with INTOSAIs communication policy. PSC will present the stan-

    dards and guidelines in a userfriendly webbased format and will on a daily basis make the edi-

    torial changes necessary without affecting the texts endorsed by INCOSAI.

Through, PSC will make INTOSAI’s process of providing standards and guide-

    lines more transparent. In addition to official INTOSAI documents the site will contain the final

    proposals not yet endorsed and it may also be used to publish exposure drafts and informa-tion on the planning of new ISSAIs. At the ISSAIs will be available in all official INTOSAI languages as provided by the responsible subcommittee or working group, while

    - 7 - further information on the site may be in English only. It is the responsibility of the chairs of subcommittees and working groups to forward any new draft documents to be published and suggest an ISSAI- or INTOSAI GOV-number in accordance with the classification principles.

Report this document

For any questions or suggestions please email